Greg Stuart: This is Building Better CMOs. Let's get back to my conversation with Michelle Barbeau, the CRO and former CMO of eHealth Insurance.
So Michelle, a bunch of really interesting stuff here. So I'd be curious to see where you kind of go on this one. And I sent your team, and you know the sort of big question here is what do we as the marketing industry, as marketers, where might we be missing the mark? What do we maybe not fully understand or maybe even fully appreciate about marketing? What do you think that we would be better as marketers if we did, if we really dug in there and really had a better comprehensive understanding? You're giving where we've maybe probably not prioritized well, where we need to prioritize. How ever you want to go at that, but what do you think that is, Michelle, in your experience?
MB: I'll tell you my thesis is that marketers need to realize that they need to be the voice and agents of change in the organization because they sit at this unique intersection of really understanding the consumer in a way that other functions maybe often don't, right? People can have opinions on the message, the media placement, but at the end of the day, great marketers are the ones that can walk in their consumers' shoes, understand what that consumer will actually respond to, and therefore they need to represent that voice in the organization. They need to make sure that voice has a seat at the table in decisions. But also they are then marrying the consumer understanding with what the organization's strengths and ability to deliver that value that ultimately are going to drive the financial performance. We've talked about I have a passion for data and that's because we need to be able to drive growth. So it's not just being an agent of change for the sake of change, but it is grounded deeply in what the consumer needs and what the organization can deliver. And I think marketers get a unique view of looking across all of those components: what's going on in the industry and the competitive set and the consumer and the organization and the financial needs, and being able to bring that picture and recommendation forward in the organization.
GS: So what makes that kind of interesting as I listen to you, it's a one-two step. They're not disconnected. So we definitely have to understand the consumer better. It's funny, I've been listening to a celebrity podcast a little bit and I hear the actors always talk about being true to their character, understand your character, so you're kind of doing a variation of that. You're remaining true to what the company is, which you provide with the insight that the consumer needs. And you're right, others in the company certainly don't study that. The CFO doesn't, CTO, CIO, and nobody else really studies that in the way that you will and know it and for a fact, like you said, you got the in lock from the research you did. Okay, but I think what you're also really advocating for there, I guess, is kind of the courage to push that point or push points based on that insight. You're not just saying we need to know the customer better and reflect the customer, you're saying, but you've got to step in and really lead that, is really I think your core point here, right, Michelle? Is that right?
MB: That is absolutely right, and let's bring it back to getting comfortable with discomfort, but you have a responsibility to the organization. I do think that there's parts of marketing that can feel very subjective. And so the CFO might have an opinion on the message or, "Can't we just tell a consumer to go do this, and then they'll just magically go do this." But we are the ones who think they might think of that because maybe they're thinking through the lens as if they were the consumer.
GS: Yes.
MB: Marketers know that they are not the consumer. They know that when they put that consumer hat on, I am literally transforming and walking in the shoes of my consumer, and so I need to represent that voice to the organization. That opinion is really important.
GS: I really am struck, though, Michelle. And I don't know if I got this before here when we were talking about it, but it really is that two part that you have to be willing to take a stand to push a point of view, which might even be somewhat unfavorable. I mean, marketers have a terrible habit. Anytime I feel like I'm the customer, it makes me really nervous.
MB: Yes, yes.
GS: That's funny you agree to that so quickly.
MB: To be honest, because I was sitting here thinking about that. I mean most of our business is for Medicare.
GS: Yeah.
MB: I am not over 65, believe it or not. So if I am making...
GS: I could believe that. The listener's not going to see you on video. Let me vouch for the listener. She's far from 65. I can attest to that, but go ahead.
MB: So it's very dangerous if I sit here and make decisions...
GS: Totally.
MB: ... on my behalf or what I think is best instead of as a 65-, 70-, 80-year-old senior, and what do they need?
GS: Anytime when I sat on the agency, I did the agency business for the first 10 years of my life. I think you were an agency person too originally, right? Yeah.
MB: Yes.
GS: Anytime I would sit in a meeting, I'd hear somebody reflect a point about what the consumer is, but it felt very much like that person or their lifestyle. I was like, I'm suspicious.
MB: Got to be skeptical. You've got to be skeptical when you start to hear that. That's exactly right.
GS: I'm like, I don't know. And then putting yourself in another consumer's shoes and you're right, nobody else in the company is really going to be able to do it. Absolutely not. I mean there's just no way. Unless you sit and pay attention and read the research and really form a point of view, there's no way you're going to get there. Especially, at dare I say... All due respect. I don't know your CFO, your CFO, or CTO, I'll just use broad titles there. Yeah, I mean what are the chances? I mean over time, maybe some of them are wired that way and can get there, but as a general rule, very hard if you're not studied or trained in that. Interesting.
MB: Yes.
GS: Do you have an example of where you've had to push a consumer point of view that you're not so sure those in the team or the company would've appreciated? It doesn't have to be eHealth, but have you ever been in a situation like that? Can you think of anything?
MB: Maybe I can say it this way. This happens pretty regularly in marketing, but there are CEOs that get very passionate about media placement, and I have heard lots of examples of times where...
GS: Oh, don't even get me started. Oh my god, go ahead.
MB: Well, you know what I'm going to say.
GS: Oh, I know exactly what you're going to say.
MB: Marketers need to put up billboards, as an example, right? In the city, in the neighborhood where the CEO lives. Now marketers look at all the data, and you're an expert in that. Is that the right place? Well, no, but the CEO has a passion for and needs to feel like they're seeing that message out there. Right? I see, let's just say, competitors with that same sort of billboard and I want us out there as well. And so it runs counter to the data and is that the right point to show up for that consumer, as an example.