JENNIFER: So I'm playing a little bit of that role of how is this a priority? How is it in service of our brand position? And what's next?
GREG: Yeah, yeah, no, I love [that] strategy is more about what not to do.
JENNIFER: What not to do. That's right.
GREG: Yes. So much, so much. And it's so easy to get kind of distracted. So listen, the whole purpose of Building Better CMOs, the whole intention of the podcast for me is to be a listener to CMOs like yourself to understand where the challenge is. It's my job as the trade association head and for the Marketing Media Alliance to go out and try to address and fix those things or to find solutions or insight or knowledge or innovation or whatever it might be that helps address the big questions that, for some reason, that either the consultancies aren't going to do or that often that the agency doesn't really get to ... There's a whole host of things around that. And the challenge for marketers, we keep finding a lot of new stuff all the time. Okay. So as you look out over, what do you think in your ... You can answer this a couple of different ways.
What do you think marketers don't appreciate enough? What do you think they don't understand? What do you think are ... It could be just gaps in our knowledge and learning. Think something outside the box on that. What do you think that we probably need to pay more attention to but we're just not there yet as an industry?
JENNIFER: We talked a little bit about this. Maybe we nipped at the edges of this earlier, but I think that the role that championing the customer and the power of that role within a big company can play is an immense one.
I think often CMOs are coming to the table and wearing that hat relative to their vertical. And the challenge I think for ... It's acute for me right now, but I think it's probably the case for many CMOs is to come to the table wearing that hat with a horizontal view and really thinking about how that customer information that you have, whether it's all of the data that we talked about, or if it's customer research and mindset, etc., can serve all of the different business functions. And to do that, I think you have to position yourself or you have to wear those shoes and you have to think about it through their lens. An example might be if I went and did a brand audit, which I recently have done, and I've found that the uniform that we wear in our stores plays a really critical role in what people feel and think about our brand because our people are so trusted and they're such an integral part of the experience for a customer.
If an associate is wearing their uniform and it's over badged or looks a certain kind of way and a customer can't interpret what's most important, it can throw off the customer experience. When I'm armed with this data, I have a choice to either go to our operational leader and say, "Hey, you got a problem with your uniform. You need to work on the uniforms for the store." Or I can say, "Hey, here's the end-to-end experience that we want to create. Here's why this particular time or moment in the journey is so powerful, and here's the outcome that could drive if we were to make the changes that we would recommend." And so it's one tiny little use case of many to say, are we thinking horizontally? Are we thinking on behalf of the entire enterprise and the end-to-end customer journey or are we just thinking about what marketing can do as a part of its role?
GREG: Are you having to play that role because sometimes others just, they don't do their own research and know, or is it because you have a different perspective? Or because ultimately the CMO should be responsible for how the customer responds?
JENNIFER: I think it's the latter, and that might be a culture that's different here than at other companies. I mean, no one company is the same. I think I'm lucky enough — it's a very lucky position to be in — but I think also can be challenging equally to be in a position where I think our leaders expect me to be the voice of the customer. So there is an expectation that if I have the full customer analytics team and I have the research team, etc., that I'm the one that's sitting at the table representing that. The question is, am I representing it through the lens of marketing or am I representing it through the lens of Lowe's? I just think that that's a really big untapped challenge today in our industry is chief marketing officer is different than chief customer officer in terms of title and yet is it and should it be?
I don't think so. I don't need a title to represent the customer.
GREG: And it is because you have the unique data asset that not everybody has. Is that true or not necessarily?
JENNIFER: Maybe. I don't know where customer research and insights and analytics sit in other functions. So maybe, Greg, that's fair. I mean, if that's not in your function, maybe you would feel less inclined to play that role, but I think it does sit in a lot of marketers' functions.
GREG: Now, when we talked in advance, and you've referenced that here some, but you also have a real responsibility too around the P&L at the company, or an orientation to the P&L, I should say, maybe I think is maybe better.
JENNIFER: Yeah. A responsibility to it.
GREG: A responsibility. There you go. Yeah, because not all marketers really ... And not all marketers in my experience think about that.
JENNIFER: Yeah, I think that's fair. What I would say is it's probably a bit of my upbringing, but it doesn't stop there. That is an expectation that I have of all of the leaders on my team, that they understand the sales plan. They look at it daily. Some of them look at it hourly because we have access to it hourly.
And that they feel equally as responsible for delivering on that sales plan as with the merchant or the operations team. Now, are we responsible for delivering every one of those sales? No, we're responsible for a portion of those sales that are driven by marketing. And importantly, we are held to a traffic plan that delivers to those sales. So we build an annual, a quarterly, monthly, down to a weekly traffic plan, both for store and for the site. And that's what we're held accountable to. And so I want my team to feel very much the responsibility of if we are behind or not pacing to plan, what are we going to do about it?
GREG: And so I've now run the MMA over 10 years. About 10 years ago, I had a private session with a bunch of CMOs, the biggest of the CMOs that were out there at the time, GM, T-Mobile, others. Okay. It was interesting, we did ask them a question, a throwaway question, "What's the role of marketer, or what's the role of marketing? What's the role of the CMO?" It's only supposed to be a 10-minute conversation because we were getting to another topic. One hour later —
JENNIFER: (laugh) I believe that.
GREG: We never got to question two because —
JENNIFER: I believe that.
GREG: Nobody in the room agreed on what the point of question one was. Okay. And they all had different answers, and all their answers were good, but it was very ... I thought, wow, how can a CEO and board understand marketing if we're all different? This is not good. I realize businesses have nuanced differences and you could emphasize, but we're not clear. Okay. So part of what the MMA did is we stepped in and we said it's really around growth. And we've now shifted that. And this is what I think I'm hearing you say is that we've shifted this focus to profitable growth. And I don't know that marketers have really taken responsibility for profitable growth or think about it that way. I hear them say things like, oh, we have a right to win with that customer. That's their segmentation strategy. I go, "I don't know what that means."
They'll think about a return on ad spend. A return on ad spend isn't the answer. It really does need to be tied back to profitability because of what it costs to acquire those customers. And especially if you get in the whole short-term, long-term discussion, that becomes a huge issue if you don't understand those. So I don't know. Is that resonating with you?
JENNIFER: Have you recently read "Be a Sequoia, Not a Bonsai"? Have you read that book?
GREG: No.
JENNIFER: Okay.
GREG: Say it again for the listener, though, if you could.
JENNIFER: "Be a Sequoia, Not a Bonsai."
GREG: Okay, got it. Okay.